Head to Head
| Date | Division | Home | | Away | | Result |
| 2021/10/24 | E1 | Barnsley | (0) 2 | Sheffield United | (0) 3 |
A |
| 2018/04/07 | E1 | Barnsley | (1) 3 | Sheffield United | (0) 2 |
H |
| 2015/11/28 | E2 | Barnsley | (0) 1 | Sheffield United | (1) 1 |
D |
| 2015/04/04 | E2 | Barnsley | (0) 0 | Sheffield United | (1) 2 |
A |
| 2010/12/11 | E1 | Barnsley | (1) 1 | Sheffield United | (0) 0 |
H |
| 2009/11/09 | E1 | Barnsley | (0) 2 | Sheffield United | (0) 2 |
D |
| 2008/11/08 | E1 | Barnsley | (0) 1 | Sheffield United | (1) 2 |
A |
| 2008/03/22 | E1 | Barnsley | (0) 0 | Sheffield United | (0) 1 |
A |
| 2002/03/09 | E1 | Barnsley | (1) 1 | Sheffield United | (1) 1 |
D |
| 2000/12/09 | E1 | Barnsley | (0) 0 | Sheffield United | (0) 0 |
D |